WCB Topic · Patents and lawsuits
The Robot Vacuum Wars Have Moved to Court
Chinese robot makers that once defended themselves against Dyson and iRobot now sue each other. WCB tracks 32 cases on three continents.
World Clean Biz · Updated 21 Nov 2026 · 32 cases, checked against court records

On 5 June 2024, two days after Dreame applied, a court in Quanzhou ordered Roborock to stop selling two of its newest robot vacuums, the P10 Pro and P10S Pro. It was the run-up to 618, China's biggest online shopping festival. Roborock pulled the robots and, by one report, lost more than 20,000 sales.
A month later the Supreme People's Court revoked the order. It found no urgency and an unclear basis for infringement. By then the festival was over.
That case shows how competition in cleaning appliances now works. A patent suit is no longer only a claim for damages. Timed well, it can take a rival's product off the shelf when it matters most. Since 2024, the industry's biggest names have filed suits at a pace not seen before.
- 32
- cases tracked
- 25
- filed since 2024
- 11
- at Europe's Unified Patent Court
- 12
- still open
A ban can matter more than a win
Pre-suit orders in China and fast injunctions in Germany can stop sales within days, long before anyone rules on whether a patent was infringed.
Europe made each case bigger
The Unified Patent Court opened in 2023. One order can stop sales in up to 18 countries, and it is now the busiest forum on this list.
The defendants became plaintiffs
Chinese makers were once mainly sued by iRobot and Dyson. Now they sue each other: Roborock and ECOVACS alone have six cases on three continents.
Who sues whom
Each arrow points from the company that sued to the company it sued. The number is how many cases.
→
3 cases
→
3 cases
→
3 cases
→
3 cases
→
2 cases
→
1 case
→
1 case- Papst→
1 case - Papst→
1 case
→
1 case
→
1 case
→
1 case
Roborock and ECOVACS: a fight on three continents
The two best-known Chinese robot-vacuum brands now sue each other in Texas, in German courts, at the Unified Patent Court and in China. Each side has brought three cases since August 2025.
So far only Roborock has orders in its favour: two Munich injunctions reported to cover ECOVACS's DEEBOT N20 models. ECOVACS's order to inspect Roborock robots at IFA Berlin was revoked, and four cases are still open.
ECOVACS sued Roborock · 3
Roborock sued ECOVACS · 3Sealing-structure patent EP 4 011 266
Roborock's first claim against ECOVACS at the Unified Patent Court.
UPC-CFI-0003142/2026Read
Invention patent; a local retailer is co-defendant
Hearing listed for 15 May 2026; no judgment published.
(2026) Min 05 Min Chu 755Read
Robot localisation patent EP 3 808 512
Filed against Roborock's German company.
UPC-CFI-0000604/2026Source
Show all 6 casesShow fewer
Two injunctions against DEEBOT N20 models
Reported to concern the DEEBOT N20 Plus and N20 Pro Plus and modular-cleaner patent EP 3 231 340. The court confirmed the orders but not their content.
21 O 12347/25 · 7 O 12785/25Source
Order to inspect Roborock robots at IFA Berlin
Revoked on 19 Dec 2025 because ECOVACS had not said the robots were on sale on Amazon; appeal rejected 16 Mar 2026.
UPC_CFI_834/2025 · UPC_CoA_3/2026Read
Robot task-area patent US 11,850,753
Against Beijing Roborock and its Hong Kong arm Shallwin. Motions argued in autumn 2026; last docket entry 26 Oct 2026.
2:25-cv-00900 (E.D. Tex.)Source
Dyson and Dreame: from vacuums to hair stylers
After more than 20 suits in China ended in a 2023 settlement, Dyson took the fight to Europe, and to hair care. The Unified Patent Court has twice barred Dreame stylers.
The next question is how far the court can reach. Whether it can cover Spain through Dreame's EU representative is now before the EU Court of Justice.
Dyson sued Dreame · 3
Both sides, China · 1Hair-styler patent EP 3 119 235; Dreame Dazzle
Covers the UPC countries and Spain; the request for the UK was refused.
UPC_CFI_2255/2025Source
Appeal on the newer Airstyle Pro and Pocket Neo
Injunction extended to the other accused stylers; whether the UPC can reach Spain through Dreame's EU representative was referred to the EU Court of Justice (C-196/26).
UPC_CoA_789/2025 · 813/2025Source
Hair-styler patent EP 3 119 235; Airstyle and Pocket
Older Airstyle and Pocket barred in the UPC countries and Spain; Airstyle Pro and Pocket Neo first found not to infringe.
UPC_CFI_387/2025Source
Show all 4 casesShow fewer
More than 20 suits by both sides
Mixed results: a Dreame vacuum cleared, RMB 150,000 against Dreame over a hair-dryer design, a Dyson hair-dryer patent invalidated. All settled in 2023 through mediation at the Supreme People's Court (reported).
Tianjin No. 3 Intermediate Court, Hebei High Court and othersSource
Dyson and SharkNinja: the oldest rivalry, now quiet
Dyson first sued over the Shark Rocket's design in 2014 and lost in 2018. A 2024 Unified Patent Court injunction against the Shark Detect Pro was lifted on appeal that December.
The US suits on both sides were settled in February 2025. It is the only rivalry here with no open case.
Dyson sued SharkNinja · 3
SharkNinja sued Dyson · 1Nine patents on Shark stick, handheld and corded vacuums
Settled; case closed 3 Feb 2025. Terms not public.
2:24-cv-00386 (E.D. Tex.)Source
Hand-held vacuum patent EP 2 043 492; Shark Detect Pro
Injunction for Germany and France granted 21 May 2024, lifted 3 Dec 2024; Dyson ordered to pay SharkNinja's costs.
UPC_CFI_442/2023 · UPC_CoA_297/2024Source
Omachron cyclone patents against Dyson cordless sticks
Brought with patent partner Omachron; SharkNinja also asked for a ruling that FlexStyle does not infringe a Dyson patent. Settled and dismissed, February 2025.
1:23-cv-11277 (D. Mass.)Source
Show all 4 casesShow fewer
Three design patents against the Shark Rocket
Summary judgment of no infringement, March 2018; Dyson dropped its appeal on 30 Jul 2018.
N.D. Ill.Source
Dreame and Roborock: two strikes in one summer
Dreame's pre-suit ban in Quanzhou, described at the top of this page, was revoked by the Supreme People's Court within a month.
In August 2024 a Düsseldorf court issued a default judgment banning the accused Roborock products in Germany; Roborock said it had never been served and would appeal (reported). WCB has found no new case between them since.
Dreame sued Roborock · 2
Roborock fought back · 1Utility model DE 21 2023 000 072 U1
Sales of the accused products banned in Germany; Roborock said it had not been served and would appeal. Appeal result not public (reported).
Düsseldorf Regional CourtSource
Roborock's review of the Quanzhou ban
The court found no urgency and an unclear basis for infringement. The first such review decided by its IP tribunal.
(2024) Zui Gao Fa Zhi Min Fu No. 1Source
Pre-suit ban on Roborock P10 Pro and P10S Pro
Granted two days after Dreame applied; Roborock pulled the robots before the 618 festival, losing a reported 20,000+ sales.
Quanzhou Intermediate People's CourtSource
What to watch
- Awaiting decisionPapst Licensing v. ECOVACS, UPC MunichHeard 13 Oct 2026. The same court dismissed Papst's claim against Roborock in August.
- EU Court of JusticeCan the UPC reach Spain? (C-196/26)Referred in Dyson v. Dreame. The answer affects how far any UPC injunction can go.
- OpenRoborock's first UPC claim against ECOVACSFiled in Munich on 31 Aug 2026 over a sealing-structure patent.
- PausedBeatbot v. Zodiac, CaliforniaStayed while the US Patent Office reviews three Zodiac patents.
Where the cases are fought, and what a win gets you
- 11Unified Patent CourtOne injunction can cover up to 18 EU countries.
- 11US federal courtsDamages and jury trials. Chervon won a USD 3.99m verdict against TTI.
- 5Chinese courtsPre-suit bans and damages, such as RMB 8.869m for Dreame against ECOVACS (reported).
- 3US ITC (Section 337)Import bans at the US border. iRobot used one against 13 makers and sellers.
- 2German courtsFast national injunctions, such as Roborock's two Munich orders against ECOVACS.
All 32 cases
Newest first. ECOVACS includes its Tineco brand.
32 cases
- TTI, Milwaukee and R&B v. Chervon and Joe GalliTrade secrets and the hiring of former TTI staffUS · IllinoisOpenRead
- SharkNinja v. online sellersPatent suits against several Chinese online sellersUS · MassachusettsFiledSource
- Versuni (Philips) v. DreameElectric-mop patent EP 3 169 210; Dreame Mira MopUPC · The HagueInjunctionRead
- Roborock v. ECOVACSSealing-structure patent EP 4 011 266UPC · MunichOpenRead
- Papst Licensing v. RoborockRoom-recognition patent EP 3 030 943UPC · MunichDismissedRead
- Kärcher v. TinecoFloor-cleaning roller patent EP 3 079 553UPC · DüsseldorfOpenRead
- Roborock v. ECOVACSInvention patent; a local retailer is co-defendantChina · QuanzhouOpenRead
- Dyson v. DreameHair-styler patent EP 3 119 235; Dreame DazzleUPC · HamburgInjunctionSource
- Dyson v. DreameAppeal on the newer Airstyle Pro and Pocket NeoUPC · Court of AppealInjunction extendedSource
- Milwaukee v. Ingersoll RandImpact-tool patentsUS · DelawareOpenSource
- ECOVACS v. RoborockRobot localisation patent EP 3 808 512UPC · DüsseldorfOpenSource
- Roborock v. ECOVACSTwo injunctions against DEEBOT N20 modelsGermany · Munich2 injunctionsSource
- ECOVACS v. RoborockOrder to inspect Roborock robots at IFA BerlinUPC · DüsseldorfRevokedRead
- ECOVACS v. RoborockRobot task-area patent US 11,850,753US · TexasOpenSource
- Dyson v. DreameHair-styler patent EP 3 119 235; Airstyle and PocketUPC · HamburgPartly grantedSource
- Beatbot (Xingmai) v. ZodiacBeatbot asks for a ruling that its pool robots do not infringeUS · CaliforniaPausedSource
- Investors v. iRobot and former officersSecurities class action over 2024–25 statementsUS · New YorkOpenSource
- Papst Licensing v. ECOVACSRobot-control patent EP 3 494 446; DEEBOT modelsUPC · MunichOpenSource
- Zodiac v. WyboticsCamera-navigation pool-cleaner patents; WYBOT robotsUS · TexasOpenSource
- Chervon v. TTIFive EGO lawn-mower patentsUS · DelawareUSD 3.99m verdictRead
- Dreame v. ECOVACSRotating cleaning-unit patent; four DEEBOT modelsChinaRMB 8.869mSource
- Dreame v. RoborockUtility model DE 21 2023 000 072 U1Germany · DüsseldorfDefault judgmentSource
- Roborock v. DreameRoborock's review of the Quanzhou banChina · Supreme People's CourtBan revokedSource
- Dreame v. RoborockPre-suit ban on Roborock P10 Pro and P10S ProChina · QuanzhouLater revokedSource
- Dyson v. SharkNinjaNine patents on Shark stick, handheld and corded vacuumsUS · TexasSettledSource
- Dyson v. SharkNinjaHand-held vacuum patent EP 2 043 492; Shark Detect ProUPC · MunichLifted on appealSource
- SharkNinja v. DysonOmachron cyclone patents against Dyson cordless sticksUS · MassachusettsSettledSource
- Bissell v. TinecoSelf-cleaning wet-dry vacuum patentsUS · ITCPartly wonRead
- iRobot v. SharkNinjaRobot-vacuum patents; Shark IQ robotsUS · ITCImport ban, later liftedSource
- Dyson and Dreame, both sidesMore than 20 suits by both sidesChina · several courtsSettled 2023Source
- iRobot v. bObsweep, Hoover, iLife and othersiRobot against 13 robot-vacuum makers and sellersUS · ITCImport banRead
- Dyson v. SharkNinjaThree design patents against the Shark RocketUS · IllinoisDyson lostSource
How we built this list
Every case is checked against court records where they are public: CourtListener for US courts, Unified Patent Court decisions, US ITC notices and Chinese court rulings. Cases known only from press reports are marked "reported". Unless a court has ruled, the claims are allegations. WCB updates this page when a case moves; send corrections through the contact page.
Key questions
Why are Roborock and ECOVACS suing each other so much?
They compete for the same premium buyers in China, Europe and the US, and both now hold large patent portfolios. Each side has picked fast forums: ECOVACS the Eastern District of Texas and the UPC in Düsseldorf, Roborock the Munich Regional Court, the UPC in Munich and a court in Quanzhou. None of the infringement claims had been finally decided by 21 November 2026.
What is a preliminary injunction, and is it final?
It is a temporary order that stops sales while the main case runs. It is not a final finding of infringement and can be lifted on appeal, as Dyson's injunction against SharkNinja was in December 2024. Dyson's injunctions against Dreame and Versuni's against Dreame were still in force when this page was updated.
Why does Dyson v. Dreame matter beyond hair stylers?
The Hamburg court stopped sales in Spain, which is not in the UPC system, by acting against Dreame's EU authorised representative. The Court of Appeal asked the EU Court of Justice whether that is allowed. The answer will decide how far any patent owner can reach with one UPC order, and whether the representative that Chinese brands must appoint to sell in the EU can be targeted.
Who is Papst Licensing?
A German company that licenses and enforces patents rather than making products. It bought robot-navigation patents from the insolvent RobArt and sued Roborock and ECOVACS at the UPC in June 2025. The Munich division dismissed its claim against Roborock in August 2026.
How does WCB choose which cases to list?
Cases between companies that make or sell cleaning appliances, pool robots, lawn equipment or power tools, where WCB can identify the parties, the forum and a case number or court report. Claims are shown as allegations unless a court has ruled. Cases known only from press reports are marked 'reported'. Readers can send corrections or new cases to WCB.
Latest news
- TTI Sues Chervon and CEO Joe Galli Over Trade Secrets and Hires
- Kärcher Brings Floor-Cleaning Patent Claim against Tineco
- JUVE Reports Dismissal of Papst Patent Claim against Roborock
- Roborock Files UPC Sealing-Structure Claim against ECOVACS
- Court Listing Identifies Roborock–ECOVACS Patent Hearing
- UPC Rejects ECOVACS Appeal over Roborock Evidence Order
- UPC Revokes ECOVACS Inspection Order against Roborock
Analysis
A Viral Mop Has Set Off a Patent Fight Between Philips and Dreame
Bissell Files a Section 337 Investigation Against Tineco in the U.S.
Bissell vs. Tineco: Patent Details
Follow-up on the Lawsuit That Changed the Robot Vacuum Industry
The Lawsuit That Shaped the Handheld Vacuum Industry
The Two Sides of Dyson
One Text Message and a 'Covert Channel': Inside TTI's Lawsuit Against Chervon and Joe Galli
TTI Strikes Back: Where Its Lawsuit Against Chervon and Joe Galli Could Go