UPC Rejects ECOVACS Appeal over Roborock Evidence Order
The ruling concerns an inspection at IFA 2025.
News date:

Part of the WCB topic:The Robot Vacuum Wars Have Moved to Court
The Unified Patent Court's Court of Appeal upheld the withdrawal of an ECOVACS evidence-preservation order against Roborock on March 16, 2026. Case UPC_CoA_3/2026 concerned information supplied when ECOVACS sought permission to inspect products at IFA 2025 without first hearing the other side.
According to EPLAW's account of the appeal order, ECOVACS had presented the Berlin exhibition as a unique opportunity to obtain evidence. The application had not fully disclosed the availability of direct purchases through Amazon in Germany or the possibility of a test purchase. The Court of Appeal considered those omissions relevant to the original request.
The appeal followed the Düsseldorf Local Division's December 19, 2025 revocation of the inspection order. The appellate court emphasized the duty to provide complete and accurate information in an application made without the opposing party present. Information supplied later could not repair the shortcomings in the initial application.
The outcome left the revocation in place, with confidentiality protections continuing for material obtained through the inspection. It settled this dispute about the evidence-gathering procedure. It did not decide whether the products infringed a patent or whether the patent itself was valid, issues that require their own assessment in the underlying litigation.
Explore The Story
Related companies & products
Company & brand profiles
Related analysis & guides
AnalysisAfter the FCC Robot Ban, What Paths Remain for Chinese Robot Vacuums and Mowers?Fifteen companies have FCC approval for foreign-produced robots, and none is Chinese. What that reveals, and where a way through could come from.
Read article
Practical guideTineco FLOOR ONE S9 Master vs Roborock F25 ACE Pro: Hot Water, Foam and HandlingCompare Tineco FLOOR ONE S9 Master and Roborock F25 ACE Pro floor washers by stain treatment, suction, tanks, runtime, lay-flat height, drying and price.
Read article
Practical guideNarwal Flow 2 vs Roborock Qrevo Curv 2 Flow: Track Mop or Roller, Height and PriceCompare Narwal Flow 2 and Roborock Qrevo Curv 2 Flow by mop design, body height, suction, pressure, edges, dock and US price, using official figures.
Read articleKeep Reading

